Skip links

Different Shades of Green

I came across the carbon-emission maps at CoolClimate.org by accident yesterday, from a mention in Kate Wagner’s twitter feed. Ms. Wagner is best known for McMansion Hell, but has been branching out into other architectural and urbanism critique. The maps are fascinating for what they have to say about our assumptions and actually addressing carbon emissions (and, therefore, climate change).

You see more greenery in suburbia than in cities. That’s true in general and it’s true in New York, despite the million trees initiative. But “green” in the sense of environmental friendly is more complex than the mere presence of plants. The top map at the first link is the interactive map that lets you look at carbon emissions across the US based on location and source. The second and third maps make the point I want to discuss. The second map – “Average Household Carbon Footprint – Eastern United States” – shows the eastern seaboard from Connecticut south to Virginia. There are green (low carbon emissions) areas along the left side of the map and on the Delmarva peninsula, where population densities are low. That’s no surprise. There is a wide stripe of red and orange (high carbon emissions) following the dense settlement from Connecticut, past NYC, across New Jersey, through eastern Pennsylvania and central Maryland, and ending in eastern Virginia. That’s no surprise either. The twist is that you can pick out the densest settlements – the major cities – because they are little islands of green. The combination of multiple dwellings (instead of single-family houses), a greater reliance on mass transit (instead of cars), shorter travel distances in daily life, and shorter local travel distances for food and other goods adds up.

The third map shows carbon emissions from transportation in the New York area. New York City and the immediately adjacent urban areas (Yonkers and Mount Vernon to the north, Hudson and the more urban part of Bergen Counties in New Jersey to the west) are green; most of the lower-density suburban areas are red. (There’s a definitional issue here: Yonkers is a suburb of New York but it’s a city in its own right.) There’s a streak of green and yellow running southwest from NYC that is the route of the Pennsylvania Railroad, which still does a lot of work bringing commuters into the city. The line dividing red from green near the Queens/Nassua border at the east edge of NYC is dramatic, and represents the difference between car culture and transit culture more than anything else. The housing and general built environment of eastern Queens is not so much more urban than the adjacent areas of Nassau County. Car ownership per household in Queens was 62% in 2018, with roughly equal numbers of people commuting to work by car and by subway (both stats are much more car-centric than NYC as a whole), while Nassau was over 90% car ownership per household in 2017 and some 69% of commuters drove solo. So that sharp line on the map is about behavior rather than the built environment.

The shortest possible summary: green comes in all shades, including city gray.

Tags: