I have mixed and contradictory reactions to “WholeTrees is smartly repurposing timber across the Midwest” by Jamie Evelyn Goldsborough. Certainly it’s true that the use of barely-processed tree trunks and branches is greener than the use of any other structural material. The energy and carbon that go into buildings show up in the production of materials, in the fabrication of useful building elements from those materials, and in transportation of the materials and elements. The use of intact pieces of trees eliminates the first, greatly reduces the second, and reduces the third. So far, so good.
The structural use of such trees is limited by their strength. The Festival Foods building shown uses the trees used in trusses, which is a good idea in that small-diameter trees can be used efficiently, but also increases the amount of fabrication and metal connectors required. Using trees as beams or girders would be limited by the size available: obviously the trees are feasible any place trimmed lumber is ordinarily used, but it is unlikely that stronger steel or reinforced-concrete beams could be replaced by trees without using assemblies like the trusses. The larger trees shown in the two schools are harder to come by: in ordinary construction, most of the wood we use is from smallish-diameter farmed trees.
There are fire issues. It’s possible to build fire-rated structure using wood, with heavy-timber framing as an example that’s been around for well over 100 years. But that kind of construction is heavily dependent on precise fit of the wood pieces to prevent hot gases from passing through floors and roofs during a fire. “Untrimmed trees” and “precise fit” are two ideas that don’t fit together very well, so we’re back to needing a lot of fabrication to get a good overall fire rating.
Finally, as the photos of the built projects make clear, this is a small percentage of the total material in the building. It helps – every little bit helps – but let’s not kid ourselves that a building with ordinary gypsum-board interiors is a revolution in green.
The article describes a real change. I can’t call it a new idea, because untrimmed trees have always been used for posts and other structure when no one would see them, but it’s a change in how these elements are perceived and used. It’s difficult to place it into a broader context. How much does this reduce carbon emissions and energy use? It’s hard to say, and that’s the problem.
